Mondoweiss on ‘Court Jew’ Elie Wiesel [updated]

For some people, the holiday tradition of charitable giving for good causes means donating to sites that work hard all year round to depict Israel as an abomination that should have no place in a civilized world. Unsurprisingly, people who like to donate for a daily dose of hate have some choice: one example I described last week is The Electronic Intifada (EI); another site with a similar agenda is Mondoweiss.

Compared to EI, Mondoweiss is rather modest – their fund-raising goal is just $40 000, and they even promise a gift for donations over $60: appropriately, it is the recent book of Shlomo Sand, author of the widely discredited “Invention of the Jewish People,” who seems resolved to serialize his flights of fancy and has come out with another installment on “The Invention of the Land of Israel.” Interestingly, none of the two books are mentioned on Sand’s page at Tel Aviv University, where he is a full professor at the Department of History.

But let’s stay with the professors at Mondoweiss, because the site doesn’t just offer Professor Sand’s book as reward for donations. There is also a “feature” written by Marc H. Ellis, whom Mondoweiss describes as “an author, liberation theologian, and Distinguished Visiting Professor, University for Peace, Costa Rica.”

Mondoweiss EWiesel

It’s arguably a company Professor Sand deserves: Ellis is a rather controversial figure, as is even reflected in a Mondoweiss post urging readers to support an apparently unsuccessful petition endorsed by a gallery of well-known “anti-Zionists” who spoke out when Ellis faced dismissal from Baylor University.

But to know who Ellis is and what he stands for, it is enough to read one of the recent installments for his pompously titled “Exile and the Prophetic”-series at Mondoweiss.

Ellis’s post on “Elie Wiesel and the history of the court Jew” is an almost unreadable concoction of incoherent ramblings that isn’t worth summarizing. Suffice it to say that Ellis takes Elie Wiesel’s contacts with influential people like the Clintons as a point of departure for some ruminations about the history of “Court Jews.” But according to Ellis, Wiesel is not just a “Court Jew,” because supposedly he “also symbolizes the crucified Jew, Jesus, since Jesus was persecuted through no fault of his own – as was Wiesel in the Holocaust – and Jesus was Jewish, like Wiesel.”

Based on this, Ellis concludes:

“Being a Court Jew and the Crucified Jew – the combination is Wiesel’s genius. His invitation to the dinner tables of the powerful is thus highly charged.

In America, Wiesel represents a politics infused with spirituality. He plays the part to the hilt but here’s the caveat. Wiesel is 84 years old. His Court Jew/Crucified Jew shelf-life is decreasing daily.”

Not quite satisfied with this effort at scraping the bottom of the barrel, Ellis throws in the suggestion that perhaps Netanyahu should be regarded “as Israel’s Court Jew” and that it would be worthwhile to ponder the question “Has Israel become the Court Jew par excellence?”

Suggestions for printable words to describe Ellis’s outpourings are most welcome.

Perhaps this is what the Mondoweiss call for donations really means when they boast that the site “push[es] the issues others shy away from.” With the support of readers, Mondoweiss hopes to “be even louder in 2013.” Astonishingly, the site seems to qualify for tax-deductible contributions and accepts donations through the “Network for Good.”

This sounds all the more Orwellian considering the fact that Mondoweiss has often been accused of antisemitism – including by people who have some qualifications to judge the matter. Under the apt title “Can we call Mondoweiss anti-Semitic yet?,” Liam Hoare has recently posted a lengthy review of some of the related controversies.  He ends his post by looking at Ellis’s ruminations on the soon-to-be-dead Court Jew Elie Wiesel in the context of some of the other views that Mondoweiss pushes so fearlessly:

“Ellis’ screed cannot help but say a little something about the publication it appears in. After all, if a media organisation believes that Israel is a failed state, that Israelis are racist, colonial settlers and occupiers, that Jews who celebrate Hanukkah exhibit bloodlust, that Jews organised into cabals wield a disproportionate amount of power over the media and the organs of government, that Jews covet power and control the direction of United States foreign policy, it follows that it is not out of character for it to play host to an article so uncultured, so unlettered, and so heinous that a drifter who stands out in the street, shouting and hollering with a cardboard sign and selling pencils from a cup would be embarrassed to have his name attributed to it.”

Indeed, this looks very much like yet another example of just how slippery the slope from anti-Zionism to antisemitism really is. And at the time of this writing, Mondoweiss readers have donated some $13 000 to get more of the same.

* * *

Cross-posted from my JPost blog.



Just to illustrate the weird world of Mondoweiss with another current offering: a recently posted piece asks “Who’s afraid of the Qassams?” The argument – if that’s what it can be called – is that “stopping Palestinian rockets is not a plausible explanation for Israeli attacks [on Gaza].” The reason is supposedly that the rockets from Gaza threaten “mostly Mizrahi, usually lower-class, Jewish Israelis” and that somehow suits the Israeli government just fine, because “Israeli ‘security’ policies […are] simultaneously a ruling-class strategy of social control and a framework for capitalist accumulation.” And all this means that it was extremely clever of the Qassam Brigade to address the Israeli public during a press conference on 17 November, claiming: “It was your leadership …that dragged you into this and into the shelters to score cheap political points.” According to Mondoweiss wisdom, this was an “open anti-government appeal to the people of Israel” which “was well-placed.”

Well, the Qassam Brigade clearly knew what they were doing when they included Mondoweiss among the 11 Twitter accounts they follow…


14 responses to “Mondoweiss on ‘Court Jew’ Elie Wiesel [updated]

  1. Good post. It’s interesting that Ellis should choose the concept of court Jew in order to engage his ideas because in a sense he is one himself. He runs a one-man Jewish Studies department at a Baptist university. He has somehow ingratiated himself with the powers that be there and convinced them that he is able to represent ‘The Jews.’ His ideological position makes him a very pleasing and non-threatening Jew to those who may be flirting with Supersession. His views on the Jewish establishment aren’t antithetical to the portrayal of the Jewish hierarchy in Jesus’ time and so on. Baylor students and Mondoweiss readers are probably too ignorant to challenge his narrative.
    On the other hand they probably think that Ellis’ obfuscatory writing is a manifestation of genius.

  2. Pingback: Glenn Greenwald and the Islamists | The Warped Mirror

  3. Pingback: Cheering a new ‘I Hate Israel Handbook’ - Anti-Israelism, Anti-Semitism - SPME Scholars for Peace in the Middle East

  4. Pingback: Cheering a new ‘I Hate Israel Handbook’ [updated] | The Warped Mirror

  5. Mondoweiss’ Weiss is a Jewish born Neo-Nazi

  6. I can’t stand these sanctimonious hypocrites like ellis who find religious justification for their hatred and blatherings

  7. Pingback: Another libel in the making | The Warped Mirror

  8. Pingback: Vassar and the BDS war on campus | The Louis D. Brandeis Center Blog

  9. Pingback: Vassar And The BDS War On Campus - Anti-Israelism, Boycotts, Divestments and Sanctions (BDS) - SPME Scholars for Peace in the Middle East

  10. Pingback: Nakba propaganda for Pope Francis | The Warped Mirror

  11. Pingback: Shlomo Sand resigns from being an invented Jew (or something like it) | The Warped Mirror

  12. Pingback: Islamist terror attacks: just another opportunity to demonize Israel (Petra Marquardt-Bigman) – 24/6 Magazine

  13. I have noticed you don’t monetize your site, don’t waste your traffic,
    you can earn additional cash every month because you’ve got high quality content.
    If you want to know how to make extra bucks, search for: Mertiso’s tips best
    adsense alternative

  14. I have checked your page and i’ve found some duplicate
    content, that’s why you don’t rank high in google’s search results,
    but there is a tool that can help you to create 100%
    unique content, search for; boorfe’s tips unlimited content

Leave a Reply to TobiasChief Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s